Clinical Study

Modified Suction-Assisted Cartilage Shaver for Axillary Osmidrosis

Table 2

Comparison of different methods in axillary osmidrosis (AO) management.

MethodsAdvantagesDisadvantagesIndicated patients

Conservative managementTopical antiperspirants(i) Noninvasive  
(ii) Easy to use
(i) Temporary effects  
(ii) Poor efficacy
Mild to moderate AO patients
Botulinum toxin injection(i) Good efficacy  
(ii) Noninvasive
(i) Need periodic use to maintain the efficacy  
(ii) Pain during the injection  
(iii) High cost  

Invasive management (to remove the apocrine glands)Direct excision of dermis and subcutaneous tissues ± skin excision(i) Good efficacy  
(ii) Under local anaesthesia
(i) Large wound   
(ii) Discomforts during postoperative periods  
(iii) Higher rates of hematoma formation, skin necrosis, keloid formation, and wound infection
Moderate to severe AO patients
Curettage(i) Moderate to good efficacy  
(ii) Smaller wound and less painful than direct excision  
(iii) Under local anaesthesia
(i) Complications depend on the physician experience
Ultrasonic liposuction(i) Moderate to good efficacy  
(ii) Small incision wound  
(iii) Short recovery time  
(iv) Under local anaesthesia
(i) Complications depend on the physician experience
Laser-assisted(i) Moderate to good efficacy  
(ii) Small incision wound  
(iii) Short recovery time  
(iv) Under local anaesthesia
(i) Higher recurrence rate than liposuction and surgery  
(ii) Higher complication incidence than the liposuction and surgery
Microwave-based(i) Good efficacy   
(ii) No surgical wound  
(iii) Short learning curve  
(iv) Under local anaesthesia
(i) Require multiple sessions to achieve better results  
(ii) Postoperative pain, swelling, and numbness (could be temporary)   
(iii) Possibility to injure the brachial nerve  
(iv) High cost
Suction-assisted cartilage shaver(i) Good efficacy  
(ii) Under local anaesthesia   
(iii) Better removal of the apocrine glands
(i) Long learning curve  
(ii) Complications depend on the physician experience

SympathectomyUpper thoracic sympathectomy(i) Moderate to good efficacy(i) Need general anaesthesia  
(ii) Compensatory hyperhidrosis  
(iii) Possibility of nerve injury  
(iv) Risk of pneumohemothorax