Research Article

The Heterogeneous Effects of FDI and Foreign Trade on CO2 Emissions: Evidence from China

Table 4

Results of panel unit root tests.

VariablesLevelFirst difference
Fisher ADFPPLLCFisher ADFPPLLC

CO220.922(1.000)12.227(1.000)-1.471(0.071)180.493(0.000)157.604(0.000)-8.568(0.000)
FDI48.416(0.858)36.450(0.993)-0.237(0.406)258.098(0.000)566.982(0.000)-13.547(0.000)
TRADE31.844(0.999)37.991(0.988)-3.004(0.001)258.445(0.000)283.188(0.000)-15.568(0.000)
GDP47.844(0.871)9.671(1.000)-3.184(0.001)109.447(0.000)116.958(0.000)-7.301(0.000)
ENC93.574(0.004)13.298(1.000)-7.356(0.000)168.118(0.000)180.824(0.000)-8.338(0.000)
URB57.068(0.584)113.371(0.000)-5.644(0.000)210.254(0.000)248.986(0.000)-9.850(0.000)
INDUS54.068(0.691)27.283(1.000)-2.818(0.002)167.560(0.000)178.243(0.000)-9.419(0.000)
ENS59.887(0.480)30.826(0.999)-3.236(0.001)259.630(0.000)328.425(0.000)-13.175(0.000)
POP84.081(0.022)159.431(0.000)-3.968(0.000)190.182(0.000)494.071(0.000)-7.034(0.000)
K112.991(0.000)32.505(0.999)-7.064(0.000)100.376(0.001)132.666(0.000)-3.789(0.000)
PG156.678(0.000)209.700(0.000)-8.861(0.000)208.064(0.000)268.010(0.000)-9.320(0.000)

Note: the significance probabilities for the corresponding tests are reported in parentheses.