Review Article

Aluminum-Induced Entropy in Biological Systems: Implications for Neurological Disease

Table 1

Common sources of Al compounds and their immunoneurotoxicological effects in humans and animals.

Aluminum source/compoundDose & durationRouteSpeciesAdverse effects

Standard infant feeding solution~20 μg/kg/day,
>10 days
Intravenous (parenteral)Human, premature infantsReduced developmental attainment at the corrected post-term age of 18 months, as evidenced by significantly lower Bayley Mental Development Index (BMDI) scores (mean loss of one point on the BMDI/day of full intravenous feeding, after adjustment for potentially confounding factors) compared to infants fed with Al-depleted solutions [31].

Al-containing dialysis fluid (derived from Al-sulfate treated tap water)1 ppm, chronic
(2–5 years)
Intravenous Human, dialysis patients (15–61 years old at the start of the dialysis treatment)Speech impairments (stuttering, dysarthria, dyspraxia, and motor aphasia), movement disorders (twitches, tremors, myoclonic jerks, seizures, and motor apraxia), cognitive impairments and behavioural changes (progressive dementia, paranoia, confusion, and psychosis), and death [32].

Al-containing antacidsChronicOralHuman infantsCraniosynostosis (premature ossification of the skull and obliteration of the sutures) [33].

Various dietaryChronicOralElderly human subjectsImpaired visuomotor coordination, poor long-term memory, and increased sensitivity to flicker (correlated with high Al-serum levels) [34].

Al sulfate 
(present as flocculant in potable water supplies, accidentally released in high amounts)
500–3000 x the acceptable limit under European Union Legislation (0.200 mg/L), chronic (15 years)OralHuman adult (female, 44 years old)Sporadic early-onset β amyloid angiopathy (Alzheimer’s-related disease), difficulty in finding words, progressive dementia, visual hallucinations, headache, anxiety, cerebral ischemia, and death [35].

Al-containing food pellets0.5–1.7 mg/kg/day (typical human), chronic (22–32 months)OralRats, 6 months old at the start of treatmentCognitive deterioration and impaired performance in learning tasks, impaired concentration, and behavioral changes including confusion and repetitive behaviour [36].

Al lactate500–1000 ppm, chronic (during gestation and lactation)OralMice damsHind limb paralysis, seizures, and death (dams), lower neurobehavioral development and altered performance on a neurobehavioral test battery in pups (foot splay, forelimb, and hind limb grip strengths reduced) [37].

Al hydroxide as a vaccine adjuvant1–17 doses of Al-containing vaccines (hepatitis B, hepatitis A, and tetanus toxoid) in the period of 10 years prior to disease diagnosisIntramuscular injectionHuman adult macrophagic myofasciitis (MMF) syndrome patients (mean age 45 years)MMF typical clinical manifestations: myalgia, arthralgia, chronic fatigue (disabling fatigue >6 months), muscle weakness and cognitive dysfunction (overt cognitive alterations affecting memory, and attention manifested in 51% of cases) [3841].  
Typical histopathology: presence of granulomatous myopathological lesion comprised of Al-hydroxide-loaded macrophages at the site of vaccine injection (usually deltoid muscle); persistence of Al long-term, up to 8–10 years in postinjection mice [38, 39, 42].  
15–20% MMF patients concurrently develop an autoimmune disease, most frequently being multiple sclerosis-like demyelinating disorders, Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, and diffuse dysimmune neuromuscular diseases (i.e., dermatomyositis, necrotizing autoimmune myopathy, myasthenia gravis, and inclusion body myositis); even in the absence of overt autoimmune disease, low titres of autoantibodies, increased inflammatory biomarkers, and abnormal iron status commonly detected in exposed mice [38, 39].

Al hydroxide as a vaccine adjuvant14 injections over a 6-month periodSubcutaneousSheep, male 3 month old lambs“Sheep adjuvant syndrome” first identified following mass-vaccination for bluetongue; experimentally reproduced by repetitive injection with Al-containing vaccines [14]; observed in acute form (affecting 25% of exposed flocks, 0.5% animals within a flock) and chronic phase form (affecting 50–70% of all exposed flocks and up to 100% of animals within a given flock).  
Acute phase symptoms: lethargy, reluctance to move, bruxism (teeth grinding), transient blindness, nystagmus (rapid abnormal eye movements), stupor, abnormal behavior, disorientation, and a low response to external stimuli, seizures, and occasionally death; histopathological lesions mainly consisting of acute meningoencephalitis (similar to those observed in humans postvaccination) and demyelinating foci  
Chronic phase symptoms: severe neurobehavioral outcomes including restlessness, compulsive wool biting, generalized weakness, muscle tremors, loss of response to stimuli, ataxia, tetraplegia (paralysis of all four limbs), stupor, coma, and death. Inflammatory lesions (multifocal neuronal necrosis and neuron loss in both dorsal and ventral column of the gray matter) and presence of Al in CNS tissues [43].

Al hydroxide as a vaccine adjuvant2 injections,  
2 weeks apart
Subcutaneous injection (behind the neck)Mice, 3 months old CD-1 maleMotor neuron degeneration and apoptosis, motor function deficits, decrease in strength, cognitive deficits, and decreased performance in learning tasks, decrements in spatial memory, activation of microglia [44, 45].

Al oxide fumes, occupational exposure0.13–1.95 mg/m3, chronicInhalationHuman, adults
(mean age 39 years)
Headache, emotional irritability, concentration difficulty, insomnia, mood lability [46].