Review Article

A Review of Underwater Localization Techniques, Algorithms, and Challenges

Table 3

Analysis of UASNs and underwater localization algorithms.

Localization algorithmsSelection methodologyAdvantagesDrawbacks/issues

CL [41]Use a control sink.Locate nodes at both condition: postprocessing or at the end.Required centralized center.
HL [42]Apply hydrophones/TDoA.Adopt standard oceanographic localization issues.Range is limited.
MAS [45]Range estimates.Provide precise localization.No error estimation is performed.
3D-MASL [46]Use DET (broadcasting).Limited energy consumption.Transmission rate is variable.
ALS [46]Central sink/RSS.Reduce energy consumption.Unable to estimate the exact location.
CL [51]Automatic localization.Reduce localization errors.Valid only for limited nodes.
AAL [53]ToA/AUV.Time-synchronized.Invest more energy.
SL [57]TDoA.Required no time synchronization.Channel modeling error is not estimated.
DNR [58]GPS/acoustic.Reduce communication cost.Do not consider the sensor mobility.
LDB [59]AUV/3D deployment.Localization error estimation.Unable for 3D-free drifting UASN.
UPS/TPS [61]TDoA/extension of TWSN.Use for oil, gas, and sea exploration.Applicable only for outdoor WSN/not for ToA.
WPS [62]Based on the premise of synchronized clock.Low energy consumption and low localization latency.Work only in a finite region.
USP [63]Use hydrophone stations and GPS nodes.Work in both 2D and 3D environments.Nodes reside in the overlapping area while mapping from 2D to 3D.
AFLA [67]AUV/nodes with a particular device.No need of anchor nodes.Only depend on the neighbor nodes, no communication with anchors.
SBRAL [68]Surface water communication links.No need for LoS/ToA.Link quality is not convenient.
SLMP [36]Surface buoys and anchor nodes.Reduce communication cost.Not suitable for dynamic environment.
ToA [70]Acoustic/targets must be synchronized.Most frequently used for UASN.Time synchronization is required.
TDoA [70]Known transmission time.Do not depend on the transmission time of source.High cost and energy consumption.
AoA [70]Based on the arrival angles.All unknown nodes can detect incident signal angles.Ultrasound receiver increases the cost.
RSSI [70]Depend on the strength of received signal and path loss impact.Applicable in asynchronous scenarios.Loss caused by multipath fading.