Research Article
Design and Maintenance Optimisation of Substation Automation Systems: A Multiobjectivisation Approach Exploration
Table 1
Data set regarding the gadgets.
| | Parameter | Value | Source |
| | Preventive maintenance | 110 €/h | SIANI-IST | | Corrective maintenance | 100 €/h | SIANI-IST |
| | TS acquisition cost | 7,000 € | IST [34] | | TS TFmin | 1 h | — | | TS TFmax | 525,600 h | Mission time | | TS TFλ | 0.1·10−6 failures/h | CISCO [36] | | TS TRmin | 1 h | — | | TS TRmax | 7 h | TRμ + 3·TRσ | | TS TRμ | 4 h | CISCO [36] | | TS TRσ | 1 h | (TRμ–TRmin)/3 | | TS TMmin | 2,190 h | TMmax/2 | | TS TMmax | 4,380 h | NERC 2007 [37] | | TS TCMmin | 1 h | Round (TRmin/2) | | TS TCMmax | 4 h | Round (TRmax/2) |
| | MU acquisition cost | 3,500 € | IST [34] | | MU TFmin | 1 h | — | | MU TFmax | 525,600 h | Mission time | | MU TFλ | 6.0047·10−6 failures/h | Scheer and Dolezilek [35] | | MU TRmin | 2 h | — | | MU TRmax | 14 h | TRμ + 3·TRσ | | MU TRμ | 8 h | Kanabar and Sidhu [4] | | MU TRσ | 2 h | (TRμ–TRmin)/3 | | MU TMmin | 2,190 h | TMmax/2 | | MU TMmax | 4,380 h | NERC 2007 [37] | | MU TCMmin | 1 h | Round (TRmin/2) | | MU TCMmax | 7 h | Round (TRmax/2) |
| | Cnt.IED acquisition cost | 3,537.50 € | IST [34] | | Cnt.IED TFmin | 1 h | — | | Cnt.IED TFmax | 525,600 h | Mission time | | Cnt.IED TFλ | 6.0047·10−6 failures/h | Scheer and Dolezilek [35] | | Cnt.IED TRmin | 2 h | — | | Cnt.IED TRmax | 14 h | TRμ + 3·TRσ | | Cnt.IED TRμ | 8 h | Kanabar and Sidhu [4] | | Cnt.IED TRσ | 2 h | (TRμ–TRmin)/3 | | Cnt.IED TMmin | 2,190 h | TMmax/2 | | Cnt.IED TMmax | 4,380 h | NERC 2007 [37] | | Cnt.IED TCMmin | 1 h | Round (TRmin/2) | | Cnt.IED TCMmax | 7 h | Round (TRmax/2) |
| | ESW acquisition cost | 2,600 € | IST [34] | | ESW TFmin | 1 h | — | | ESW TFmax | 525,600 h | Mission time | | ESW TFλ | 9.9265·10−6 failures/h | Scheer and Dolezilek [35] | | ESW TRmin | 2 h | — | | ESW TRmax | 14 h | TRμ + 3·TRσ | | ESW TRμ | 8 h | Kanabar and Sidhu [4] | | ESW TRσ | 2 h | (TRμ–TRmin)/3 | | ESW TMmin | 2,190 h | TMmax/2 | | ESW TMmax | 4,380 h | NERC 2007 [37] | | ESW TCMmin | 1 h | Round (TRmin/2) | | ESW TCMmax | 7 h | Round (TRmax/2) |
| | Prt.IED acquisition cost | 3,537.50 € | IST [34] | | Prt.IED TFmin | 1 h | — | | Prt.IED TFmax | 525,600 h | Mission time | | Prt.IED TFλ | 6.0047·10−6 failures/h | Scheer and Dolezilek [35] | | Prt.IED TRmin | 2 h | — | | Prt.IED TRmax | 14 h | TRμ + 3·TRσ | | Prt.IED TRμ | 8 h | Kanabar and Sidhu [4] | | Prt.IED TRσ | 2 h | (TRμ–TRmin)/3 | | Prt.IED TMmin | 2,190 h | TMmax/2 | | Prt.IED TMmax | 4,380 h | NERC 2007 [37] | | Prt.IED TCMmin | 1 h | Round (TRmin/2) | | Prt.IED TCMmax | 7 h | Round (TRmax/2) |
|
|
