Renal Replacement Therapy in the Critical Care Setting
Table 2
Early versus Delayed RRT strategy: a comparison of ELAIN, AKIKI, and IDEAL-ICU studies.
ELAIN (23)
AKIKI (24)
IDEAL-ICU (25)
Design
RCT
RCT
RCT
Setting
Single centre
Multicentre (31 ICUs)
Multicentre (29 ICUs)
Population
Predominantly postoperative patients; 47% post cardiac surgery.
Predominantly medical patients with septic shock
Patients with septic shock
(i) Main inclusion criteria
(i) KDIGO stage 2 (ii) NGAL>150 mg/ml (iii) Critical illness including at least one of severe sepsis/vasopressor support/refractory fluid overload/SOFA score >2.
(i) KDIGO stage 3 (Cr>354micromol/L or anuria for >12 hrs or urine output<0.3 ml/kg/hr for 24 hrs) (i) Critical illness (mechanical ventilation or vasopressor)
(i) Failure stage of RIFLE criteria: Oliguria (urine output <0.3 ml per kilogram of body weight per hour for ≥24 hours), Anuria for 12 hours or more, or a serum creatinine level 3 times the baseline level or ≥4 mg per deciliter (≥350 μmol per litre) (ii) Septic shock <48 hrs of commencing vasopressor support
(i) Main exclusion criteria
Preexisting renal disease eGFR <30 ml/min/1.73m2
Preexisting renal disease CrCl < 30 ml/min/1.73m2
End-stage renal disease and obstructive nephropathy
>48 hrs of failure stage of RIFLE criteria or absolute indications developing
RRT requirement in delayed group (%)
91
51
62
Method of RRT
CVVHDF
Multiple modalities: >50% initially on IHD
Multiple modalities: 45% initially on IHD
Primary outcome
(i) Mortality in early vs delayed RRT
At 90 days: 39.3% vs 54.7%
At 60 days: 48.5% vs 49.7%
At 90 days: 58% vs 54%
(ii) value
0.03
0.79
0.38
Secondary outcome
(i) Duration of RRT early vs delayed (median days)
9 vs 25
NA
4 vs 2
(ii) Ongoing requirement for RRT
At 90 days: 13% vs 15%
At 60 days: 2% vs 5%
At 90 days: 2% vs 3%
Conclusion
Early RRT compared with delayed initiation of RRT reduced mortality over the first 90 days.
No significant difference in mortality between an early and delayed strategy for the initiation of RRT therapy. A delayed strategy averted the need for RRT in a large number of patients.
No significant difference in 90-day mortality between early and strategy of RRT among septic shock patients.