Research Article
Shear Bond Strength of Three Orthodontic Bonding Systems on Enamel and Restorative Materials
Table 2
Descriptive statistics on SBS values for the different bonds used on enamel and prosthetic surfaces.
| Surface material | Adhesive | ā | Shear bond strength |
| Enamel | Transbond XT primer | Mean | 15.51 | | 10 | SD | 3.49 |
| Enamel | Scotchbond | Mean | 12.09 | | 10 | SD | 3.85 |
| Enamel | iBond | Mean | 6.96 | | 10 | SD | 2.00 |
| Enamel | Total | Mean | 11.52 | | 30 | SD | 4.73 |
| SR Adoro | Transbond XT primer | Mean | 8.82 | | 10 | SD | 3.39 |
| SR Adoro | Scotchbond | Mean | 9.03 | | 10 | SD | 3.02 |
| SR Adoro | iBond | Mean | 8.99 | | 10 | SD | 1.94 |
| SR Adoro | Total | Mean | 8.94 | | 30 | SD | 2.75 |
| Filtek Supreme XTE | Transbond XT primer | Mean | 9.32 | | 10 | SD | 2.80 |
| Filtek Supreme XTE | Scotchbond | Mean | 16.61 | | 10 | SD | 2.38 |
| Filtek Supreme XTE | iBond | Mean | 11.43 | | 10 | SD | 2.58 |
| Filtek Supreme XTE | Total | Mean | 12.45 | | 30 | SD | 4.00 |
| Wisil | Transbond XT primer | Mean | 7.62 | | 10 | SD | 2.37 |
| Wisil | Scotchbond | Mean | 4.69 | | 10 | SD | 1.84 |
| Wisil | iBond | Mean | 5.39 | | 10 | SD | 2.89 |
| Wisil | Total | Mean | 5.90 | | 30 | SD | 2.65 |
| Dispersalloy | Transbond XT primer | Mean | 6.62 | | 10 | SD | 1.61 |
| Dispersalloy | Scotchbond | Mean | 6.71 | | 10 | SD | 1.70 |
| Dispersalloy | iBond | Mean | 9.28 | | 10 | SD | 1.92 |
| Dispersalloy | Total | Mean | 7.54 | | 30 | SD | 2.10 |
| Herador | Transbond XT primer | Mean | 3.78 | | 10 | SD | 1.50 |
| Herador | Scotchbond | Mean | 5.14 | | 10 | SD | 1.89 |
| Herador | iBond | Mean | 4.69 | | 10 | SD | 1.63 |
| Herador | Total | Mean | 4.54 | | 30 | SD | 1.72 |
| e.max Press | Transbond XT primer | Mean | 7.07 | | 10 | SD | 2.62 |
| e.max Press | Scotchbond | Mean | 17.20 | | 10 | SD | 3.21 |
| e.max Press | iBond | Mean | 3.44 | | 10 | SD | 2.05 |
| e.max Press | Total | Mean | 9.24 | | 30 | SD | 6.46 |
| ZirCAD | Transbond XT primer | Mean | 4.29 | | 10 | SD | 2.18 |
| ZirCAD | Scotchbond | Mean | 12.33 | | 10 | SD | 4.15 |
| ZirCAD | iBond | Mean | 10.01 | | 10 | SD | 3.08 |
| ZirCAD | Total | Mean | 8.88 | | 30 | SD | 4.65 |
| Mark II | Transbond XT primer | Mean | 6.37 | | 10 | SD | 2.72 |
| Mark II | Scotchbond | Mean | 11.16 | | 10 | SD | 3.76 |
| Mark II | iBond | Mean | 10.85 | | 10 | SD | 3.13 |
| Mark II | Total | Mean | 9.46 | | 30 | SD | 3.83 |
|
|